Charles Raby TX DR #999109 Denied COA by 5th Circuit Concerning LI Litigation

Started by Jeff1857, January 16, 2009, 09:01:40 PM

previous topic - next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Go Down

JT

FACEBOOK...I am there too!!


Har Har Har.  I've found your Facebook profile! :P
JT's Ridiculous Quote of the Century:
"I'm disgusted with the State for even putting me in this position."
-- Reginald Blanton, Texas death row.  As of October 27, 2009, Reggie's position has been in a coffin.

Jeff1857

Death row inmate's bid for release delayed


A Harris County judge wants to hear testimony from a forensic expert before deciding whether new DNA evidence is favorable to death row inmate Charles D. Raby, condemned in the 1994 murder of an elderly woman.

Raby's conviction is receiving new scrutiny because DNA tests contradict evidence from the Houston Police Department crime lab in his case. His lawyer is seeking his release or a new trial.

This morning, state District Judge Joan Campbell delayed closing arguments in an evidentiary hearing on the DNA evidence to allow testimony from the city's expert, Patricia Hamby. She has called the original testimony and lab work by HPD analyst Joseph Chu "incorrect ... and not supported."

Hamby, who is based in Indiana, is expected to testify sometime next month. After her appearance, Campbell will decide whether the new evidence is favorable to Raby's case, a decision that could provide an opening for his attorney to seek his release or a new trial.

A Harris County jury sentenced Raby to death in the 1994 murder of Edna M. Franklin, 72, a grandmother who lived alone in her north Houston home.

At Raby's trial, jurors heard testimony from HPD crime lab analyst Chu, who told them that tests conducted on scrapings from under Franklin's fingernails were inconclusive.

Years later, as revelations about chronic problems at the HPD crime lab came to light, Raby's case received a 2nd look.

Campbell ordered DNA tests on the finger nail scrapings, in which analysts at a California lab found no evidence from Raby. The tests also excluded the victim's 2 grandsons, the only people she regularly had contact with, as the sources of the scrapings.

The Harris County District Attorney's office has maintained that the new evidence is inconclusive and does not clear Raby.

(source: Houston Chronicle)


Jeff1857

Raby was finally Denied his request for LI Litigation in today's 5th Circuit Orders/Opinions. However his litigation for DNA testing and the problem with the Harris County crime lab is ongoing so he's not closer to execution.

Opinion is here:

http://www.ca5.uscourts.gov/opinions/pub/08/08-20772-CV0.wpd.pdf

turboprinz

Court Lifts Reprieve for Nicaraguan Man on Texas Death Row
The Texas Court of Criminal Appeals has lifted a reprieve it gave a Nicaraguan man a day before he was to be executed two years ago for the slaying of a Houston high school teacher during a 1997 robbery.

| May 17, 2017, at 5:44 p.m.

HOUSTON (AP) -- The Texas Court of Criminal Appeals on Wednesday lifted a reprieve it gave a Nicaraguan man a day before he was to be executed two years ago for killing a Houston high school teacher during a 1997 robbery.

The state's highest criminal appeals court had halted the scheduled August 2015 lethal injection of Bernardo Tercero after his attorneys contended Harris County prosecutors unknowingly presented false testimony from a witness at his trial in 2000 for the death of 38-year-old Robert Berger. Wednesday's ruling affirms the findings of Tercero's trial court that last year held a hearing on the claim and determined the testimony was proper.

Berger was a customer in a Houston dry cleaners shop in March 1997 and was with his 3-year-old daughter when records show Tercero came in to rob the store. Berger was fatally shot and the store was robbed of about $400. Prosecutors said Tercero was in the U.S. illegally at the time.

Tercero, now 40, argued the shooting was accidental. He testified Berger confronted him and tried to thwart the robbery, and the gun went off as they struggled. He was arrested in Hidalgo County near the Texas-Mexico border more than two years after the slaying. A second man sought in the case never has been found.

Tercero's case has attracted attention in his home country, where a clemency plea from Nicaraguan President Daniel Ortega in 2015 was forwarded to Texas Gov. Greg Abbott.

In another case, the appeals court Wednesday denied an appeal from Bartholomew Granger, condemned for the slaying of a 79-year-old woman during a 2012 shooting rampage outside the Jefferson County Courthouse.

Attorneys for Granger, 46, raised 10 challenges to his 2013 conviction and death sentence. Five issues focused on claims his trial attorneys were deficient, four raised questions about the constitutionality of the death penalty in Texas and the last contended he was denied his right to an impartial jury.

At his trial, Granger, from Houston, testified under cross-examination that he wanted the death penalty. He was convicted of fatally shooting Minnie Ray Sebolt, a bystander walking outside the courthouse in downtown Beaumont. Granger admitted he opened fire on his daughter outside the courthouse after she testified against him in a sexual assault case. He said he didn't intend to kill Sebolt.

His daughter and her mother were among three people wounded.

In a third case, the appeals court refused an appeal from Charles Raby, 47, who was sent to death row in 1994 for killing a 72-year-old woman, Edna Mae Franklin, at her Houston home. The court said the appeal focusing on DNA testing was improperly filed and did not rule on the merits of the argument. In 2015, the court upheld a lower court finding that results of new DNA tests didn't cast doubt on Raby's conviction for Franklin's 1992 stabbing death.

The appeals court also sent back to a trial court in Bastrop County the lengthy case of Rodney Reed to review claims newly discovered evidence improperly was withheld and to show prosecutors presented false and misleading testimony at Reed's trial where he was convicted and sentenced to death for the 1996 abduction, rape and strangling of 19-year-old Stacy Stites. Her body was found off the side of a road about 35 miles (56.32 kilometers) southeast of Austin.

Last month, the appeals court refused to allow additional DNA testing of evidence in the case, saying the request was meant to "to unreasonably delay the execution of his sentence or the administration of justice."

https://www.usnews.com/news/best-states/texas/articles/2017-05-17/court-lifts-reprieve-for-nicaraguan-man-on-texas-death-row
I apologize for my not perfect English. Hopefully you understand what I mean. If not - ask me. I will try to explain.

Go Up